Indo-Uralic and Afroasiatic
Revision as of 21:26, 29 October 2017 by Admin
Indo-European has been described as “a branch of Indo-Uralic which was transformed under the influence of a Caucasian substratum”[Kortlandt 2002], which would imply an invasion of Indo-Uralic-speaking peoples to a territory of previous Caucasian hunter-gatherers. Such Caucasian influence has been supported recently by the finding of a genetic contribution (probably during the Mesolithic-Neolithic transition in the steppe, see below) of a pocket of Caucasus hunter-gatherers, who seem to have weathered much of the last Ice Age in apparent isolation[Jones et al. 2015].
Long-ranging language relationships are difficult to prove. If Uralic and Indo-European shared a common ancestor – Indo-Uralic[Kloekhorst 2008] –, its ancestor could be associated to the post-Swiderian east European communities with a majority of WHG ancestry and R1b1a1a-P297 lineages, similar to the Balkan hunter-gatherers from the Iron Gates. If these people and their language expanded from central and south-east European communities of the Villabruna cluster with a majority of R1b1a-L754 lineages, certain hypothetic linguistic communities can be proposed:
It would be conceivable but controversial[Prósper 2013], for example, to give credit to the nature of Proto-Basque as of Pre-Indo-European substratum[Forni 2013][Blevins 2015] – beyond pre- and post-Roman IE superstrata[Koch 2013]. This is supported by the presence of an Iberian Eneolithic sample of R1b1a-L754 (xR1b1a1a2-M269, V88-equivalent) at Els Trocs ca. 5180 BC[Haak et al. 2015], and its potential continuity in north Iberia at least until the Bell Beaker expansion[Mathieson et al. 2017].
Proto-Afroasiatic has been proposed to have emerged in the southern fringe of the Sahara in an “upside-down” view[Bender 2007], while R1b1a2-V88 lineages (and specifically its subclade R1b1a2b1b1a-V69) have been found in north and central Africa, mainly in Chadic-speaking populations, but also in west Egypt and in the Middle East[Cruciani et al. 2010]. That lineage, probably related to the Villabruna cluster, could have crossed the Mediterranean into northern Africa quite easily before the end of the Ice Age, possibly through the southern Italian Peninsula. Such an early migration into Africa is supported by the presence of R1b1a-L761 (equivalent to L754, as the sample from Villabruna) at high frequencies among the Toubou population (34%), inhabiting Chad[Haber, Mezzavilla, Bergström, et al. 2016].
The ancestry coming from outside of Africa, related to Eurasian herders[Schlebusch et al. 2017] – found in 20%-30% in the Toubou –, is potentially linked to this migration, since a good proxy for this ancestry (before the recent study of ancient Levantine ancestry) were present-day Sardinians[Pickrell et al. 2014]. From northern Africa they could have travelled south and then east, since the Sahara was an important site of occupation and crossing of hominids during the Holocene, with Fezzan-Chad-Chotts, and Chad-Chotts-Ahnet-Moyer megalake green corridors connecting northern and central Africa – with gradual desiccation of the desert, until ca. 4000 BC[Drake et al. 2011].
This old environment could have allowed the for a west-east migration, and for a sizeable population expansion in central Saharan territory. This model would agree with Chadic languages being the most divergent of the Afroasiatic group, excluding Omotic – whose population has been shown to be mainly of sub-Saharan ancestry, in contrast with other Afroasiatic peoples[Baker, Rotimi, and Shriner 2017].
A migration of this R1b1a2-V88 lineage through Iberia seems unlikely, because there is some long-term continuity of an endemic (probably Epipaleolithic) element in Morocco until about the Neolithic expansion associated with the arrival of a Levantine Natufian hunter-gatherer component, and the appearance of haplogroup E-M96[Fregel et al. 2017], whose continuity in North Africa since then is attested from east to west[Rodríguez-Varela et al. 2017]. A migration through eastern Europe seems still less likely, given the continuity of haplogroups and the ancestry components found in samples from Anatolia, the Levant, and Egypt, although it seems to be still today the preferred model of expansion of this haplogroup[Haber, Mezzavilla, Bergström, et al. 2016].
Haplogroup R2a-M124 seems to be prevalent among (ancient and modern) Dravidians, and is also found in the Caucasus, while haplogroup Q-M242 has links to Asian and Native American populations[Huang et al. 2017].[Bomhard 2008], associated then with R-M207.
However, macro-languages are speculative, and their relationships highly controversial, with such ancient archaeological evolutions – and their relationship to population movements – quite difficult to ascertain. A still more speculative relation with an older Borean macro-family[Gell-Mann, Peiros, and Starostin 2009], for example, could be explained by certain expansions of P1-M45 lineages, which should in turn help determine dialectal evolutions.
Diachronic map of Palaeolithic migrations.
- [Baker, Rotimi, and Shriner 2017] ^ Baker, Jennifer L., Charles N. Rotimi, and Daniel Shriner. 2017. Human ancestry correlates with language and reveals that race is not an objective genomic classifier. Scientific Reports 7 (1):1572.
- [Bender 2007] ^ Bender, M. Lionel. 2007. The Afrasian lexion reconsidered. In Studies in Semitic and Afroasiatic Linguistics Presented to Gene B. Gragg, edited by C. L. Miller. Illinois: The University of Chicago.
- [Blevins 2015] ^ Blevins, Juliette. 2015. Advances in Proto-Basque Reconstruction and the Proto-Indo-European-Euskara Hypothesis. In Harvard Linguistics Circle. Harvard Linguistics.
- [Bomhard 2008] ^ Bomhard, A. R. 2008. Reconstructing Proto-Nostratic: Comparative Phonology, Morphology, and Vocabulary. Edited by A. Lubotsky. Vol. 1, Leiden Indo-European etymological dictionary series. Leiden: Brill.
- [Cruciani et al. 2010] ^ Cruciani, F., B. Trombetta, D. Sellitto, A. Massaia, G. Destro-Bisol, E. Watson, E. Beraud Colomb, J. M. Dugoujon, P. Moral, and R. Scozzari. 2010. Human Y chromosome haplogroup R-V88: a paternal genetic record of early mid Holocene trans-Saharan connections and the spread of Chadic languages. Eur J Hum Genet 18 (7):800-7.
- [Drake et al. 2011] ^ Drake, Nick A., Roger M. Blench, Simon J. Armitage, Charlie S. Bristow, and Kevin H. White. 2011. Ancient watercourses and biogeography of the Sahara explain the peopling of the desert. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108 (2):458-462. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1012231108
- [Forni 2013] ^ Forni, Gianfranco. 2013. Evidence for Basque as an Indo-European Language. JIES 41 (1 & 2):1-142.
- [Fregel et al. 2017] ^ Fregel, Rosa, Fernado L. Mendez, Youssef Bokbot, Dimas Martin-Socas, Maria D. Camalich-Massieu, Maria C. Avila-Arcos, Peter A. Underhill, Beth Shapiro, Genevieve L Wojcik, Morten Rasmussen, Andre E. R. Soares, Joshua Kapp, Alexandra Sockell, Francisco J. Rodriguez-Santos, Abdeslam Mikdad, Jonathan Santana, Aioze Trujillo-Mederos, and Carlos D. Bustamante. 2017. Neolithization of North Africa involved the migration of people from both the Levant and Europe. bioRxiv.
- [Gell-Mann, Peiros, and Starostin 2009] ^ Gell-Mann, Murray, Ilia Peiros, and George Starostin. 2009. Distant Language Relationship: The Current Perspective. Journal of Language Relationship 1:13-30.
- [Haak et al. 2015] ^ Haak, W., I. Lazaridis, N. Patterson, N. Rohland, S. Mallick, B. Llamas, G. Brandt, S. Nordenfelt, E. Harney, K. Stewardson, Q. Fu, A. Mittnik, E. Banffy, C. Economou, M. Francken, S. Friederich, R. G. Pena, F. Hallgren, V. Khartanovich, A. Khokhlov, M. Kunst, P. Kuznetsov, H. Meller, O. Mochalov, V. Moiseyev, N. Nicklisch, S. L. Pichler, R. Risch, M. A. Rojo Guerra, C. Roth, A. Szecsenyi-Nagy, J. Wahl, M. Meyer, J. Krause, D. Brown, D. Anthony, A. Cooper, K. W. Alt, and D. Reich. 2015. Massive migration from the steppe was a source for Indo-European languages in Europe. Nature 522 (7555):207-11.
- [Haber, Mezzavilla, Bergström, et al. 2016] ^ 1 2 Haber, M., M. Mezzavilla, Y. Xue, D. Comas, P. Gasparini, P. Zalloua, and C. Tyler-Smith. 2016. Genetic evidence for an origin of the Armenians from Bronze Age mixing of multiple populations. Eur J Hum Genet 24 (6):931-6.
- [Huang et al. 2017] ^ Huang, Yun-Zhi, Horolma Pamjav, Pavel Flegontov, Vlastimil Stenzl, Shao-Qing Wen, Xin-Zhu Tong, Chuan-Chao Wang, Ling-Xiang Wang, Lan-Hai Wei, Jing-Yi Gao, Li Jin, and Hui Li. 2017. Dispersals of the Siberian Y-chromosome haplogroup Q in Eurasia. Molecular Genetics and Genomics.
- [Jones et al. 2015] ^ Jones, E. R., G. Gonzalez-Fortes, S. Connell, V. Siska, A. Eriksson, R. Martiniano, R. L. McLaughlin, M. Gallego Llorente, L. M. Cassidy, C. Gamba, T. Meshveliani, O. Bar-Yosef, W. Muller, A. Belfer-Cohen, Z. Matskevich, N. Jakeli, T. F. Higham, M. Currat, D. Lordkipanidze, M. Hofreiter, A. Manica, R. Pinhasi, and D. G. Bradley. 2015. Upper Palaeolithic genomes reveal deep roots of modern Eurasians. Nat Commun 6:8912. https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms9912
- [Kloekhorst 2008] ^ Kloekhorst, Alwin. 2008. Some Indo-Uralic Aspects of Hittite. JIES 36 (1 & 2).
- [Koch 2013] ^ Koch, John T. 2013. Is Basque an Indo-European Language? JIES 41 (1 & 2).
- [Kortlandt 2002] ^ Kortlandt, Frederik. 2002. The Indo-Uralic verb. In Finno-Ugrians and Indo-Europeans: Linguistic and literary contacts. Maastricht: Shaker.
- [Mathieson et al. 2017] ^ Mathieson, Iain, Songül Alpaslan Roodenberg, Cosimo Posth, Anna Szécsényi-Nagy, Nadin Rohland, Swapan Mallick, Iñigo Olade, Nasreen Broomandkhoshbacht, Olivia Cheronet, Daniel Fernandes, Matthew Ferry, Beatriz Gamarra, Gloria González Fortes, Wolfgang Haak, Eadaoin Harney, Ben Krause-Kyora, Isil Kucukkalipci, Megan Michel, Alissa Mittnik, Kathrin Nägele, Mario Novak, Jonas Oppenheimer, Nick Patterson, Saskia Pfrengle, Kendra Sirak, Kristin Stewardson, Stefania Vai, Stefan Alexandrov, Kurt W. Alt, Radian Andreescu, Dragana Antonović, Abigail Ash, Nadezhda Atanassova, Krum Bacvarov, Mende Balázs Gusztáv, Hervé Bocherens, Michael Bolus, Adina Boroneanţ, Yavor Boyadzhiev, Alicja Budnik, Josip Burmaz, Stefan Chohadzhiev, Nicholas J. Conard, Richard Cottiaux, Maja Čuka, Christophe Cupillard, Dorothée G. Drucker, Nedko Elenski, Michael Francken, Borislava Galabova, Georgi Ganetovski, Bernard Gely, Tamás Hajdu, Veneta Handzhyiska, Katerina Harvati, Thomas Higham, Stanislav Iliev, Ivor Janković, Ivor Karavanić, Douglas J. Kennett, Darko Komšo, Alexandra Kozak, Damian Labuda, Martina Lari, Catalin Lazar, Maleen Leppek, Krassimir Leshtakov, Domenico Lo Vetro, Dženi Los, Ivaylo Lozanov, Maria Malina, Fabio Martini, Kath McSweeney, Harald Meller, Marko Menđušić, Pavel Mirea, Vyacheslav Moiseyev, Vanya Petrova, T. Douglas Price, Angela Simalcsik, Luca Sineo, Mario Šlaus, Vladimir Slavchev, Petar Stanev, Andrej Starović, Tamás Szeniczey, Sahra Talamo, Maria Teschler-Nicola, Corinne Thevenet, Ivan Valchev, Frédérique Valentin, Sergey Vasilyev, Fanica Veljanovska, Svetlana Venelinova, Elizaveta Veselovskaya, Bence Viola, Cristian Virag, Joško Zaninović, Steve Zäuner, Philipp W. Stockhammer, Giulio Catalano, Raiko Krauß, David Caramelli, Gunita Zariņa, Bisserka Gaydarska, Malcolm Lillie, Alexey G. Nikitin, Inna Potekhina, Anastasia Papathanasiou, Dušan Borić, Clive Bonsall, Johannes Krause, Ron Pinhasi, and David Reich. 2017. The Genomic History Of Southeastern Europe. bioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/135616
- [Pickrell et al. 2014] ^ Pickrell, Joseph K., Nick Patterson, Po-Ru Loh, Mark Lipson, Bonnie Berger, Mark Stoneking, Brigitte Pakendorf, and David Reich. 2014. Ancient west Eurasian ancestry in southern and eastern Africa. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111 (7):2632-2637. https://dx.doi.org/10.1073%2Fpnas.1313787111
- [Prósper 2013] ^ Prósper, Blanca María. 2013. Is Basque an Indo-European language? Possibilities and limits of the comparative method when applied to isolates. JIES 41 (1 & 2):239-245.
- [Schlebusch et al. 2017] ^ Schlebusch, Carina M, Helena Malmström, Torsten Günther, Per Sjödin, Alexandra Coutinho, Hanna Edlund, Arielle R Munters, Maryna Steyn, Himla Soodyall, Marlize Lombard, and Mattias Jakobsson. 2017. Ancient genomes from southern Africa pushes modern human divergence beyond 260,000 years ago. bioRxiv.